Dexter was on the verge of popping as I probed his prostate 3 min

3 minClub Amateur Usa - 61.2k Views -

At one point, TreyDaddie was whimpering, and then the soft, gutteral moans began, "More... more... more..." 7 min

7 minClub Amateur Usa - 124.8k Views -

Finch clinched down on my fingers as they probed his prostate 6 min

6 minClub Amateur Usa - 45.4k Views -

Klaus is CAUSA's first fair-skinned, blue-eyed, strawberry-dishwater-blonde Puerto Rican to slide onto the table. 7 min

7 minClub Amateur Usa - 49.4k Views -

Sean was engorged and throbbing throughout filming, and his flaring nostrils were certainly one of Sean's tells. 5 min

5 minClub Amateur Usa - 39.7k Views -

Mi novia quiere que me la coja enfrente de todos es su fantasía y de la cumpli 10 min

10 minAlex Marin Actor - 45.6k Views -

Stacked Wife Surprises Hunk Hubbie wt 1st Time Bi Fuck - Steve Rickz, Alexis Kay - Biphoria 12 min

12 minBiPhoria - 1.5M Views -

Next in the CAUSA Classic CUMpilation series, I decided to jump forward to 2008 when 19-year-old, active-duty AF Morgan slid onto the ClubAmateurUSA massage table. 8 min

8 minClub Amateur Usa - 31.7k Views -

With one of the best cumshots that I've on video (that Luldeek on his face), I do believe that this OG video was quite successful. 4 min

4 minClub Amateur Usa - 249.9k Views -

Since Liam had not gotten off in four days, his cawk was raring to go! 6 min

6 minClub Amateur Usa - 47.2k Views -

Although he self-identifies as gay, Elián continues to surprise himself and me in terms of the direct prostate stimulation since it's not something that he practices or participates in in his private sex life. 5 min

5 minClub Amateur Usa - 29k Views -

CAUSA's resident Hawaiian returns in his own Classic CUMpilation with Tomas' four scenes spanning from March 2004 to March 2008. 8 min

8 minClub Amateur Usa - 14.9k Views -

Casey recently reappeared on AFF, and as soon as I reviewed his most recent pix, I knew that I wanted to run his three videos as a CAUSA Classic CUMpilation. 8 min

8 minClub Amateur Usa - 33.9k Views -

Una chica le da su culito al actor más famoso de México y lo rellena todo de su semen 9 min

9 minSolo Bellezas - 329.4k Views -

Tariq's thick cock pulsed throughout the anal play with him on the edge of orgasm the entire time. 4 min

4 minClub Amateur Usa - 19.5k Views -

BI MMF THREESOME WITH SHADOW AND CODY ARIZONA! 29 sec

29 secVanessaarizonaxxx - 10.3k Views -

CAUSA Classic CUMpilation Circle Jerk Guys | Nine guys including Roman, Andy, and Mystery Guy | Four Scenes | Straight and Sexploring 8 min

8 minClub Amateur Usa - 79.2k Views -

CAUSA 012 was Leo's first foray into adult content at 20 years of age, and this blonde-haired, blue-eyed hottie later returned in CAUSA 058 (June 2004), and y'all got to see just how cute he was. 4 min

4 minClub Amateur Usa - 13.8k Views -

At 20 years of age, Quinn first slid onto the massage table in July 2007 in the 219th CAUSA video, and now, pushing into 36 years of age, Quinn is sliding on in the 779th ClubAmateurUSA video. 6 min

6 minClub Amateur Usa - 63.4k Views -

I waited years to penetrate Finch's hole. It was worth it 6 min

6 minClub Amateur Usa - 67.4k Views -

Dave swung by this week for another round on the ClubAmateurUSA.com massage table. We've not seen him since September of last year. I tried some different camera angles and had Dave play with himself some to spice things up.. 4 min

4 minClub Amateur Usa - 58.7k Views -

Gilligan's Bi-Land - A Parody - Scene 2 - Michael DelRay, Dale Savage, Dee Williams 6 min

6 minInsanevideos -

Braydyn's been working out, has let his hair grow out, & he's even more beautiful today than he was six years ago - if that's even possible. When I saw him flash his pearly whites, all I could do was GRRRWOOF and say, "Let's g 8 min

8 minClub Amateur Usa - 50.7k Views -

While his pulsing, perfect, pretty penis was Jasper's most obvious tell, it was somewhat of a challenge for me to get a read on him. 4 min

4 minClub Amateur Usa - 89.1k Views -

I got out the studded manrammer & Devlin took it like a champ 6 min

6 minClub Amateur Usa - 138.6k Views -

So, admittedly, Soren pretty much trips my trigger -- and always has since the first time I saw him at my favorite wine bar / restaurant around the corner from me in Old Town (and then later on discovered that he had a profile on AFF). 3 min

3 minClub Amateur Usa - 20.6k Views -

It's the most wonderful time of the year now that Rainer has returned to Arizona for a few months, and so, a couple of months ago when Rainer informed me that he was being relocated for work, I decided to schedule him for "Santa Cums Early.&quot 5 min

5 minClub Amateur Usa - 23.8k Views -